NRF(National Research Foundation of Korea)

About the NRF
Funding Process
Key Review Procedures for Research Support Programs
01
Preliminary Review

Review of qualifications, etc.

NRF

02
Expert Review *

1) Online Review

2) Panel Review

3) Presentation-based Review

NRF (Expert review panel)

03
PM Consultative Group

Allocation of grants in each field; review of proposals

NRF

04
Program Committee, etc

Selection of proposals; Final confirmation

MSIT, MOE

Review methods may vary depending on the characteristics of each program.

Detailed Review System
Selection Screening

Qualifications Review

· 

Review qualifications of the principle investigator, including application eligibility

Exclude projects with reasons for disqualification

Expert Review

· 

Conduct Review with expert reviewers from industry-academia-research backgrounds or by a separate review panel

Utilize the NRF’s PM (CRB and RB) and review pool

Utilize the NRF’s researcher information DB (recommendation and selection of reviewers)

Conduct selection screening based on online/panel/discussion Review in each field

· 

Conduct Review on creativity, spirit of challenge, and researcher capability and achievements according to Review indicators and criteria

Review by specialist organizations

· 

Compilation, coordination and review of selection (proposal) regarding outcomes of expert review by PM consultative group

· 

Prepare the allocation (proposal) of the number of selected projects while adjusting research grants.

Committee Review

· 

Final confirmation by the Program Implementation Committee (including comprehensive review group)

Validity of Review outcomes, selected projects, policy considerations, etc.

Notification of Selection

· 

NRF/MSIT and MOE (→ specialist organizations) → competent research institution

· 

Notification of selection: Details of research grant adjustments, etc.

Request for conclusion of agreement, access to project management system, and guidelines on required documents

Interim Review

Process of Filing Objections

· 

Organizations - objections filed → NRF

· 

File an objection within seven days after notification of selection

· 

Outcome (report) of the objection process is deliberated and notified by the NRF.

Submission of Annual Performance Plan

· 

Submission of Annual Performance Plan (competent research institution)

One or two months before the termination of research period in the pertinent year

Annual review

· 

Conduct a PM-led annual review in each field

· 

Discontinue or reduce research grants for the following year with regards to supported projects that produce inadequate research performance

· 

Review research contents (results of the previous year and research plan for the following year) and the appropriateness of research grant allocation for the following year

Final(Phase) Review

Determine continuation of support

· 

Deciding progress-management results and the scale of research grants.

· 

Notifying research institutions of progress-management results

Submission of the Final (Phase) Report

· 

Submission of the Final (Phase) Report for Review Purposes and the Self-Review Report

Phase report is submitted one month before the termination of research period and the final report before the end of research period in the pertinent year.

Expert Review

· 

Conduct Review with evaluators from industry-academia-research backgrounds

Utilize the NRF’s PM (CRB and RB) and pool of evaluators

Utilize the NRF’s researcher information DB (recommendation and selection of reviewers)

Utilize evaluators who participated in selection screening

Review by Specialist Organizations

· 

Determine project ranking and research grants based on scores and opinions from the Review

· 

Establish grade (proposal) according to expert Review outcomes

· 

Maintain statistics on Review outcomes, incentives, and penalties

Process of Filing Objections

· 

Organization - objection filed → NRF

· 

File an objection within seven days after notification of selection

· 

Outcome (report) of the objection process is deliberated and notified by the NRF.